2011 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division I All-America Teams
| First Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Amelia Willadsen | Yavapai College |
| P | Sarah Mendez | Navarro College |
| P | Ariel Zimmermman | Salt Lake Community College |
| P | Estela Pinon | Yavapai College |
| C | Veronika Fukunishi | Miami Dade College |
| IF | Jamie Prussic | Central Arizona College |
| IF | Sierra Rodriguez | Yavapai College |
| IF | Olive Naotala | Howard College |
| IF | Marina Groenewegen | College of Southern Idaho |
| IF | Bradi Wall | Iowa Western Community College |
| IF | Andrea Sullivan | Chipola College |
| OF | Jessica Soria | Arizona Western College |
| OF | Jessica Schneider | Pima Community College |
| OF | Savannah Webster | Salt Lake Community College |
| OF | Erica Wolver | Navarro College |
| DP | Megan Christensen | Wallace State Community College, Hanceville |
| Second Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Haley Johnson | Central Alabama Community College |
| P | Lindsey Rossi | Temple College |
| P | Tara Bell | Blinn College |
| P | Heather Parker |
Wallace State Community College, Hanceville |
| C | Marina Contreras |
Pima Community College |
| IF | Brittany Arredondo | Blinn College |
| IF | Alex Landon | Yavapai College |
| IF | Sienna Miller | Navarro College |
| IF | Mikkel Griffin | College of Southern Idaho |
| IF | Kenshyra Jackson | Polk State College |
| IF | Cortney McNett | Wallace State Community College, Hanceville |
| OF | Vanessa House | Yavapai College |
| OF | Vannessa Peterson | Central Alabama Community College |
| OF | Alex Yarbrough | Blinn College |
| OF | Kylee Simpson | Iowa Western Community College |
| DP | Ariel Gomez | Blinn College |
| Third Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Catherine Floyd | Polk State College |
| P | Brittany Black | Chipola College |
| P | Ashton Hughes | Western Nebraska Community College |
| P | Shannon Millman | San Jacinto College, South |
| p | Emily Leib | Temple College |
| IF | Caitlin Ortiz | Gulf Coast Community College |
| IF | Kristen Expositio | Miami Dade College |
| IF | KIara Nazario | Miami Dade College |
| IF | Sara Vaughn | Blinn College |
| IF | April Breshears | Northeast Texas Community College |
| IF | Stephanie Price | Jefferson College |
| OF | Samanatha Rich | Chipola College |
| OF | Jimeshia Bennett | Faulkner State Community College |
| OF | Katie Pierce | Wallace State Community College, Hanceville |
| OF | Jenna Clayton | Jefferson College |
| DP | Alexis Beltran | Howard College |
