2011 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division II All-America Teams
| First Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Amanda Lambrecht | Kirkwood Community College |
| P | Lauren Huber | Kankakee Community College |
| P | Tina Schulz | Louisiana State University, Eunice |
| C | Jena Malmen | Kirkwood Community College |
| C | Brianna DiGioia | Kankakee Community College |
| IF | Jami Miller | Kirkwood Community College |
| IF | Melissa Walls | Kirkwood Community College |
| IF | Chelsea Kurnat | Muskegon Community College |
| IF | Cheyenne Adams | Phoenix College |
| IF | Chelsey Rottinghaus | Labette Community College |
| IF | Morgan Allee | Iowa Central Community College |
| OF | Kelsey Gass | Kankakee Community College |
| OF | Josi VanHouten | Ellsworth Community College |
| OF | Sabeana Romero | South Mountain Community College |
| OF | Tahlisa Blosser | South Mountain Community College |
| DP | Jennifer Yazzie | South Mountain Community College |
| Second Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Shelby Dougherty | Kirkwood Community College |
| P | Lenzie Boring | Allen County Community College |
| P | Heather Abshire | Louisiana State University, Eunice |
| P | Taylor Paulson | Labette Community College |
| C | Ariel Siegel | South Mountain Community College |
| IF | Megan Risetter | Iowa Central Community College |
| IF | Sarah Gray | Parkland Community College |
| IF | Felicia Wilson | South Mountain Community College |
| IF | Haley McCall | Louisiana State University, Eunice |
| IF | Jamie Tanno | Hutchinson Community College |
| IF | Jenna Sigg | Allen County Community College |
| OF | Samantha Inman | Parkland Community College |
| OF | Gretchen Gieseking | Ancilla Community College |
| OF | Callie Umholtz | Allen County Community College |
| OF | Caitlin Dekker | Muskegon Community College |
| DP | Makenzi Anderson | Ellsworth Community College |
