2011 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III All-America Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Katie Trotter |
Gloucester County College |
| Pitcher | Ashley Snyder | Tompkins Cortland Community College |
| Pitcher | Melissa Kanouse | Sussex County Community College |
| Catcher | Andrea Schoephoerster | Anoka-Ramsey Community College |
| Catcher | Caitlyn Pipolo | Gloucester County College |
| Infield | Kristen Mickley | Middlesex County College |
| Infield | Tracey Stern | Brookdale Community College |
| Infield | Alex Hebert | Monroe Community College |
| Infield | Lindsey Sampolski | Gloucester County College |
| Infield | Randee Hanson | Anoka-Ramsey Community College |
| Infield | Jacilyn Ciran | College of DuPage |
| Outfield | Krystal Plouff | Anoka-Ramsey Community College |
| Outfield | Holly Frampton | Corning Community College |
| Outfield | Chelsea Alston | Brookdale Community College |
| Outfield | Isabelle Vogt | College of DuPage |
| Designated Player | Monica Mattison | Corning Community College |
