NCAA Division III Coaching Staffs of the Year
| Year | School |
| 2010 | East Texas Baptist |
| 2009 | Messiah |
| 2008 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire |
| 2007 | Linfield |
| 2006 | Rutgers-Camden |
| 2005 | St. Thomas |
| 2004 | St. Thomas |
| 2003 | Central College |
| 2002 | Lake Forest College |
| 2001 | Muskingum College |
| 2000 | Roanoke College (VA) |
| 1999 | Simpson College (IA) |
| 1998 | University of Wisconsin, Stevens Point |
| 1997 | Simpson College (IA) |
NCAA Division III Coach of the Year
| Year | Coach |
Institution |
| 1996 | Dee Dee Enabenter | Bridgewater State College |
| 1996 | Marge Willadsen | Buena Vista University |
| 1995 | June Walker | Trenton State College |
| 1994 | Dee Dee Enabenter | Bridgewater State College |
| 1993 | Shelley Monas | Allegheny College |
| 1992 | June Walker | Trenton State College |
| 1991 | June Walker | Trenton State College |
| 1990 | Jeff Anderson | Eastern Connecticut State University |
| 1989 | Sheilah Lingenfelter | Allegheny College |
| 1988 | Sheilah Lingenfelter | Allegheny College |
| 1987 | June Walker | Trenton State College |
