2012 NFCA High School All-American Teams
First Team | Second Team | Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kenzie Conrad |
Keystone High School (Ohio) |
| Pitcher | Tori Finucane | Bishop O'Connell High School (Va.) |
| Pitcher | Cheridan Hawkins | Anderson High School (Calif.) |
| Pitcher | Kelsee Selman |
Hudson High School (Texas) |
| Catcher | Jillian Ferraro | Bishop O'Connell High School (Va.) |
| Catcher | Taylore Fuller | Chiefland High School (Florida) |
| First Base | Jillian Galich |
Lincoln-Way North High School (Ill.) |
| Second Base | Carly Piccinich | Immaculate Heart Academy (N.J.) |
| Third Base | Julianne Rurka | Benet Academy (Ill.) |
| Shortstop | Bianka Bell | Tampa Chamberlain High School (Fla.) |
| Outfielder | Stephanie Hartness | Niceville High School (Fla.) |
| Outfielder | Maeve McGuire |
Benet Academy (Ill.) |
| Outfielder | Kiki Stokes |
Olathe East High School (Kan.) |
| Utility | Rainey Gaffin |
Legacy High School (Colo.) |
| At-Large (P) | Cara Goodwin |
Good Hope High School (Ala.) |
| At-Large (SS) | Sierra Romero |
Vista Murrieta High School (Calif.) |
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Kelsi Pardue | Allen County-Scottsville High School (Ky.) |
| Pitcher | Kailey Regester | Basha High School (Ariz.) |
| Pitcher | Steph Thomas |
Immaculate Heart Academy (N.J.) |
| Pitcher | Chelsea Wilkinson |
Alexander Central High School (N.C.) |
| Catcher | Sydney Dimon |
Notre Dame High School (N.Y.) |
| First Base |
Ashley Palmer |
Desert Mountain High School (Ariz.) |
| Third Base |
Kylie Shull |
Basha High School (Ariz.) |
| Shortstop | Jessica Ball |
Legacy High School (Colo.) |
| Utility | Samantha Show | Pearland High School (Texas) |
| At-Large (SS) | Kristen Cuyos | Pearland High School (Texas) |
| At-Large (SS) | Sandy Hawthorne |
Hauppauge High School (N.Y.) |
| At-Large (SS) | Lindsey Neyland | Evangel Christian Academy (La.) |
| At-Large (SS) | Taurie Pogue |
Mountain View High School (Idaho) |
| At-Large (SS) | Erin Pond |
Keystone High School (Ohio) |
| At-Large (SS) | Kelsey Stewart | Maize High School (Kan.) |
| At-Large (P) | Lindsay Swipas |
Champion High School (Ohio) |
| Position | Name | School |
| At-Large (UT) | CC Alvarez |
Tippecanoe High School (Ohio) |
| At-Large (P) | Haley Beam |
Pearland High School (Texas) |
| At-Large (OF) | Katie Bosler |
Carmel High School (Ind.) |
| At-Large (C) | Bri Buckley | Keystone High School (Ohio) |
| At-Large (OF) | Courtney Chelf |
Enid High School (Okla.) |
| At-Large (3B) | Jenna Kreamer |
Evangel Christian Academy (La.) |
| At-Large (2B) | Elizabeth Leonard |
Olathe East High School (Kan.) |
| At-Large (2B) | Amanda Lynn |
Lassen High School (Calif.) |
| At-Large (C) | Maddie McCracken | Olathe North High School (Kan.) |
| At-Large (UT) | Carly Mertens |
Baldwin High School (N.Y.) |
| At-Large (P) | Kelsey Nunley |
Soddy Daisy High School (Tenn.) |
| At-Large (OF) | Amani Proctor |
Buchanan High School (Calif.) |
| At-Large (UT) | Danielle Marinna Shadley |
Golden Gate High School (Fla.) |
| At-Large (P) | Casey Stangel |
Lake City High School (Idaho) |
| At-Large (2B) | Paige Wall |
North Davidson Senior High School (N.C.) |
| At-Large (P) | Jordan Weed |
Toms River High School (N.J.) |
