2012 NJCAA Division I All-America Teams
| First Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Ashley Czechner | Chattanooga State Community College |
| P | Heather Parker | Wallace State Community College, Hanceville |
| P | MaCauley Flint | Salt Lake Community College |
| P | Marina Contreras | Pima Community College |
| C | Gina Mengwasser | Seminole State College (OK) |
| IF | Lacye Walker | Chattanooga State Community College |
| IF | Maddy Woodard | Salt Lake Community College |
| IF | Olive Naotala | Howard College |
| IF | Daleigh Fossler | Iowa Western Community College |
| IF | Debra Lovelle | Midland College |
| IF | Thomasina Garza | Blinn College |
| OF | Shelby Johnson | Chattanooga State Community College |
| OF | Mya Anderson | Chipola College |
| OF | Malia Campos | Salt Lake Community College |
| OF | Jessica Neely | Crowder College |
| DP | Nicole Atkinson | North Idaho College |
| Second Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Esteella Pinon | Yavapai College |
| P | Kaci Federwisch | Blinn College |
| P | Ariel Zimmerman | Salt Lake Community College |
| P | Tanna Hinthorne | Lake Land College |
| P | Paige Mathews | State College of Florida |
| IF | Savanah Webster | Salt Lake Community College |
| IF | Lauren Payne | Wallace State Community Collge, Hanceville |
| IF | Jolene Graham | Odessa College |
| IF | Amanda Ake | Tallahassee Community College |
| IF | Jessica Loiacano | Central Arizona College |
| IF | Nikki Nail | Seminole State College (OK) |
| OF | Leandra Maly | Blinn College |
| OF | Reba Hawkins | Shelton State Community College |
| OF | Mallory Koschaqny | Lama State College - Port Arthur |
| OF | Cynbthia Pelayo | Pima Community College |
| DP | Morgan Coleman | Crowder College |
| Third Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Emily Smethhurst | Tallahassee Community College |
| P | Eva Voortman | Chipola College |
| P | Sandra Sema | Howard College |
| P | Amanda Trampe | Wabash Valley College |
| P | Rachel Brisker | Muscatine Community College |
| IF | Jamie Hockaday | Louisburg College |
| IF | Kalee Tabor | Seminole State College (FL) |
| IF | Kristina Davila | Binn College |
| IF | Carson Forge | Crowder College |
| IF | Caitlin Nichol | Muscatine Community College |
| IF | Melissa Wear | Faulner State Community College |
| OF | Hilary Chapman | Gulf Coast State College |
| OF | Brandi Heimburg | Yavapai College |
| OF | Sarah Hawryluk | Western Nebraska Community College |
| OF | DJ Hooks | San Jacinto College - South |
| DP | Connie Browder | Northwest Florida State College |
