2012 NJCAA Division II All-America Teams
| First Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| C | Desirea Gil | Phoenix College |
| C | Hally Lenzine | Marshalltown Community College |
| P | Tina Schulz | Louisiana State University, Eunice |
| P | Catie Flaucher | Kirkwood Community College |
| P | Corinne Frei | Iowa Central Community College |
| IF | Morgan Allee | Iowa Central Community College |
| IF | Haley Strawn | Cowley County Community College |
| IF | Krystal Garcia | Phoenix College |
| IF | Jenny Nelson | Kirkwood Community College |
| IF | Brittany Madsen | Iowa Central Community College |
| IF | Justine Phillips | Illinois Central Community College |
| OF | Nicole Fisher | Kirkwood Community College |
| OF | Dana Briggs | Muskegon Community College |
| OF | Laura Seemann | Cowley County Community College |
| OF | Mackenzie Chrenka | Lansing Community College |
| DP | Kayla Tatge | Kirkwood Community College |
| Second Team | ||
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Kaylee Guidry | Louisiana State University, Eunice |
| P | Gina Van Arsdall | Phoenix College |
| P | Katy Burns | Muskegon Community College |
| P | Alex Puckly | Mercyhurst North East |
| C | Makenzi Anderson | Ellsworth Community College |
| IF | Heather Lanphear | Independence Community College |
| IF | Danielle "Boo" Basch | Muskegon Community College |
| IF | Mataya Wooten | Johnson County Community College |
| IF | Ashley Adams | Kankakee Community College |
| IF | Megan Sauble | Community College of Baltimore County, Catonsville |
| IF | Chelsey Streibich | South Mountain Community College |
| OF | Alicia Ward | Kankakeee Community College |
| OF | Alexis Roman | South Mountain Community College |
| OF | Kelsey Hollier | Louisiana State University, Eunice |
| OF | Gretchen Gieseking | Ancilla College |
| DP | Jennifer Owen | Labette Community College |
