2012 NFCA NJCAA Division III All-America Team
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Kristina Morgan |
Gloucester County College |
| P | Emilie Rogers | Tompkins Cortland Community College |
| C | Amanda Reid | Joliet Junior College |
| P | Deanna Daluise | Brookdale Community College |
| C | Stephanie Wolff | College of Dupage |
| IF | Briana Molino | Gloucester County College |
| IF | Mollie Peck | Corning Community College |
| IF | Jess Patterelli | Herkimer County Community College |
| IF | Justine Mattia | Gloucester County College |
| IF | Emma Erbig | Brookdale Community College |
| IF | Stacey Braun | North Dakota State College of Science |
| OF | Chelsea Alston | Brookdale Community College |
| OF | Shannon Nevins | College of DuPage |
| OF | Steph Siriano | Herkimer County Community College |
| OF | Kristan Baker | Tompkins Cortland Community College |
| DP | Mackenzie Sherlock | Tompkins Cortland Community College |
