2013 NFCA NJCAA Division III All-America Team
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Samantha Hosey |
Brookdale Community College |
| P | Toni Secreti | Herkimer County Community College |
| P | Erin Huesser | Gloucester County College |
| C | Kathleen Sharp | Brookdale Community College |
| C | Maria Marquez | Rock Valley College |
| IF | Melissa Mackey | Gloucester County College |
| IF | Mollie Peck | Corning Community College |
| IF | Karen Caithamer | College of DuPage |
| IF | Bobbie Boehler | Brookdale Community College |
| IF | Kara Ekx | Rock Valley College |
| IF | Jessica Patterelli | Herkimer County Community College |
| OF | Courtney Paone | Brookdale Community College |
| OF | Aja Gosper | Corning Community College |
| OF | Briana Villari | Gloucester County College |
| OF | Stephanie Siriano | Herkimer County Community College |
| DP | Delaney Buckley | Herkimer County Community College |
