2014 NFCA NJCAA Division III All-America Team
| Position | Name | School |
| P | Amanda Blankenship | Rock Valley College |
| P | Toni Secreti | Herkimer CCC |
| P | Samantha Hosey | Brookdale CC |
| C | Sammy Smaldone | Herkimer CCC |
| C | Jamie Cook | Corning CC |
| IF | Ashley Sterritt | Herkimer CCC |
| IF | Gabby Citriniti | Corning CC |
| IF | Danielle Walker | Rock Valley College |
| IF | Karen Caithamer | College of DuPage |
| IF | Kaytee Keefe | Rock Valley College |
| OF | Katie Meyer | Rock Valley College |
| OF | Taylor Rizzotte | Gloucester CC |
| OF | Cassidy Brzozowski | Brookdale CC |
| OF | Sarah Heimbach | Herkimer CCC |
| DP | Lexi Haley | Monroe CC |
| At-Large | Haley Love | Rock Valley College |
