2009 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division II All-Americans
| First Team | ||
| Pos. | Name | School |
| P | Ashley Meyer | Iowa Lakes Community College |
| P | Brianna Carpenter | Lansing Community College |
| P | Jacey Juden | Cowley County Community College |
| P | Hannah Dow | Heartland Community College |
| C | Lacy Goodman | Phoenix College |
| IF | Morgan Goddard | Lansing Community College |
| IF | Brittany Martin | Iowa Central Community College |
| IF | Stephanie Ochoa | Iowa Lakes Community College |
| IF | Breayle Tackett | Cowley County Community College |
| IF | Daniela Leal | Pratt Community College |
| IF | Ashley Rosenberg | Phoenix College |
| OF | Carlie Schnoebelen | Kirkwood Community College |
| OF | Teddy Barry | Phoenix College |
| OF | Sarah Doyle | Fort Scott Community College |
| OF | Melodi Murrieta | Lansing Community College |
| DP | Tiffany Cupp | Lansing Community College |
| Second Team | ||
| Pos. | Name | School |
| P | Kylee Knop | Kirkwood Community College |
| P | Hannah Huebble | Heartland Community College |
| P | Stefanie Morong | Lansing Community College |
| P | Ashley Spencer | Cowley County Community College |
| C | Kashilia Young | Cowley County Community College |
| IF | Terra Ramsey | Danville Community College |
| IF | Tara Buchanan | Kankakee Community College |
| IF | Kristina Manser | Iowa Lakes Community College |
| IF | Christi Clevenger | Johnson County Community College |
| IF | Brittany Hess | Johnson County Community College |
| IF | Sam Elmers | Mercyhurst College |
| OF | Lizzie Andrews | Heartland Community College |
| OF | Christy Cabrera | Iowa Lakes Community College |
| OF | Hannah Somers | Fort Scott Community College |
| OF | Jordan Wright | Chesapeake College |
| DP | Chelsea Parrish | Kirkwood Community College |
Diamond Sports Catcher of the Year: Lacy Goodman, Phoenix College
adidas Golden Shoe Award: Ashley Willard, Iowa Central Community College
