1991 NSCA Division I All-America Teams
First Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Heather Compton | UCLA |
| Pitcher | Michelle Granger | California |
| Pitcher | Terry Carpenter | Fresno State |
| Catcher | Diane Pohl | Iowa |
| First Base | Julie Cavanaugh | Oregon |
| Second Base | Julie Smith | Fresno State |
| Third Base | Camille Spitaleri | Kansas |
| Shortstop | Julie Standering | Arizona |
| Outfield | Yvonne Gutierrez | UCLA |
| Outfield | Pam Stanley | Central Michigan |
| Outfield | Tricia Popowski | South Carolina |
| Utility | Lisa Fernandez | UCLA |
Second Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Karen Snelgrove | Missouri |
| Pitcher | Karen Jackson | Iowa |
| Pitcher | Missy Young | Texas A&M |
| Catcher | Erica Ziencina | UCLA |
| First Base | Julie Jones | Arizona |
| Second Base | Michelle Delloso | South Carolina |
| Third Base | Gina Lopicclol | Fresno State |
| Shortstop | Tiffany Tootle | South Carolina |
| Outfield | Rachel Brown | Arizona State |
| Outfield | Leigh Ross | Toledo |
| Outfield | Charmelle Green | Utah |
| Utility | Kelly Brookhart | Creighton |
| At-Large | Kari Blank | Minnesota |
Third Team
| Position | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Lori Harrigan | UNLV |
| Pitcher | Debbie Day | Arizona |
| Pitcher | Christy Larsen | Florida State |
| Catcher | Rhonda Rube | Northwestern |
| First Base | Julie Liljeberg | Western Michigan |
| Second Base | Missy Phillips | UCLA |
| Third Base | Kim Kostyk | Long Beach State |
| Shortstop | Shauna Bowman | Ohio State |
| Outfield | Dorsey Steamer | Southwestern Louisiana |
| Outfield | Mitch DeBree | Cal State Fullerton |
| Outfield | Colleen Holloway | Southern Illinois |
| DP/Utility | Julie Sexton | Northern Illinois |
| At-Large | Chris Parris | UNLV |
