Louisville Slugger/NSCA 1992 NAIA All-America Teams
| First Team |
||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| Pitcher | Ivy Dashkin | Mobile |
| Pitcher | Tracey Lagrimas | Hawaii-Hilo |
| Pitcher | Becky Hoddevik | Pacific Lutheran |
| Pitcher | Ann Harbin | Lander |
| Catcher | Laurie Stanley | National Louis |
| Infield | Keri Allen | Pacific Lutheran |
| Infield | Adrienne Hauk | West Florida |
| Infield |
Leah Crawford | Kennesaw State |
| Outfield |
Leta Baysinger | Pacific Lutheran |
| Outfield |
Laura Munson | Kennesaw State |
| Outfield |
Kelly McDuffie | Kennesaw State |
| DP/Utility |
Renee Leary | Wilmington |
| Second Team | ||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| Pitcher | Cindy Weibert | West Florida |
| Pitcher | Sonya Perry | Mount Mercy |
| Pitcher |
Tammie Shemenski | Columbia |
| Catcher |
Julie Wyrick | Columbia |
| Infield | Mary Murphy | IUPU |
| Infield | Lynn Benenati | West Florida |
| Infield | Melveena Starkey | Hawaii-Hilo |
| Infield |
Brenda Dobbelaar | Pacific Lutheran |
| Outfield | Leah Gatter | Pacific |
| Outfield |
Joan Russo | National Louis |
| Outfield |
Lehua Kaakimaka | Hawaii-Hilo |
| Outfield |
Kim Wright | IUPU |
| Utility | Lisa Lukach | St. Francis |
