Louisville Slugger/NSCA 1993 NAIA All-America Teams
| First Team |
||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| Pitcher | Jennifer Hilliard | Mobile |
| Pitcher | Becky Hoddevik | Pacific Lutheran |
| Pitcher | Stacey Matcuk | Georgian Court |
| Pitcher | Sherri Wright | Belmont |
| Catcher | Jill Lammers | Mount Mercy |
| Catcher | Kim Warner | Pacific |
| Infield | Sandy O'Rourke | St. Francis |
| Infield |
Andrea Farqhar | Pacific Lutheran |
| Infield |
Jenny Asbury | Wilmington |
| Infield |
Tracy Mosley | Oklahoma City |
| Infield |
Tonya Carlisle | Kennesaw State |
| Infield |
Charleste Vaughn | Mobile |
| Infield |
Adrianna Haulk | West Florida |
| Outfield |
Misty Haynes | West Florida |
| Outfield | Kelly McDuffie | Kennesaw State |
| Outfield |
Laura Munson | Kennesaw State |
| Outfield |
Lynne DiGrazia | St. Xavier |
| Utility |
Danelle Harvey | West Florida |
| Utility | Malveena Starkey |
Hawaii-Hilo |
| Utility |
Renee Leary | Wilmington |
| Second Team | ||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| Pitcher | Amy Dawson | Pacific |
| Pitcher | Brandi Farthing | Oklahoma City |
| Pitcher |
Tina Holmes | Oklahoma City |
| Pitcher |
Kelly Tafter | Kennesaw State |
| Catcher | Natalie Kulas | Oklahoma State |
| Catcher | Tony Castrey | Pacific Lutheran |
| Infield | Jill Padavano | Georgian Court |
| Infield |
Lynn Benenati | West Florida |
| Infield |
Lori Brown | Mt. Vernon Nazarene |
| Infield |
Lori Tesor | Mercy |
| Infield |
Kim Wilson | Oklahoma City |
| Outfield |
Crystal Nelson | Belmont |
| Outfield | Jennifer Johnson | West Florida |
| Outfield | Tuesday Butcher | Oklahoma City |
| Designated Player | Kim Van Fleet | West Florida |
| Utility |
Jenn Swanson | Pacific Lutheran |
| Utility |
Janelle Fischer | Pacific |
