Louisville Slugger/NSCA 1995 NAIA All-America Teams
| First Team |
||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| Pitcher | Kisha Frey | Athens State (AL) |
| Pitcher | Tammy Braithwaite | Oklahoma City |
| Pitcher | April Faircloth | Belmont (TN) |
| Catcher | Kim Stanfill | Belmont (TN) |
| Catcher | Melinda Dowlen | Athens State (AL) |
| Catcher | Jennifer Wells | Oklahoma City |
| Infield | Felisa Pascua | Hawaii-Pacific |
| Infield |
Kami Fondersmith | Athens State (AL) |
| Infield |
Tracey Mosley | Oklahoma City |
| Infield |
Melissa Dowlen | Athens State (AL) |
| Infield |
Kelly Seamons | Athens State (AL) |
| Infield |
Moose Tyler | Oklahoma City |
| Outfield |
Shelly Clark | Athens State (AL) |
| Outfield |
Kelly McKellar | Oklahoma City |
| Outfield | Chris Daily | William Woods (MO) |
| Outfield |
Megan Haug | Pacific (OR) |
| Utility |
Jodi Solana | Georgian Court (NJ) |
| Utility |
Lisa Shandy | Hawaii Pacific |
| Second Team | ||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| Pitcher | Diana Kendrick | Athens State (AL) |
| Pitcher | Tina Holmes | Oklahoma City |
| Pitcher |
Jenn Elias | Houston Baptist (TX) |
| Catcher |
Lisa Willman | McKendree (IL) |
| Catcher | Dana Lyons | Houston Baptist (TX) |
| Catcher | Katie Mahoney | Mobile (AL) |
| Infield | Chrystal Chun | Hawaii-Pacific |
| Infield |
Janell Fischer | Pacific (OR) |
| Infield |
Larissa Burns | Simon Fraser (B.C.) |
| Infield |
Teresa Sheets | Mt. Vernon Nazarene (OH) |
| Infield |
DeLane Lee | Mobile (AL) |
| Infield |
Julie Oermann | Columbia (MO) |
| Infield | Angela Massengill | Tusculum (TN) |
| Outfield | Jennifer Hopkins | McKendree (IL) |
| Outfield | Cindy Connell | Houston Baptist (TX) |
| Outfield |
Amy Dillard | Belmont (TN) |
| Outfield |
Sharon Quinn | St. Xavier (IL) |
| Utility |
Deanna Kaczynski | Westminster (PA) |
