Louisville Slugger/NSCA 1996 NAIA All-America Teams
| First Team |
||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| Pitcher | Nicole Fownes | Faulkner (AL) |
| Pitcher | Janet Gunter | Pacific Lutheran (WA) |
| Pitcher | Dolly Johnson | Oklahoma City |
| Pitcher | Mitzi Groves | Oklahoma City |
| Catcher | Jennifer Wells | Oklahoma City |
| Catcher | Kamie Fondersmith | Athens State (AL) |
| Infield | Brandy Barnett | Trevecca Nazarene (TN) |
| Infield |
Shelly Clark | Athens State (AL) |
| Infield |
Felisa Pascua | Hawaii Pacific |
| Infield |
Jennifer Howell | Bethel (IN) |
| Infield |
Melissa Thomas | Mobile (AL) |
| Infield |
Leslie Westmoreland | Athens State (AL) |
| Infield |
Lynette Williams | Hawaii Pacific |
| Infield |
Leslie Hudson | Oklahoma City |
| Outfield | Cindy Connell | Houston Baptist (TX) |
| Outfield |
Terri McCormick | Mobile (AL) |
| Outfield |
Coby Owens | Mobile (AL) |
| Outfield |
Michele Ringor | Hawaii Pacific |
| Outfield |
Heather Tang | William Woods (MO) |
| Designated Player |
Tina Holmes | Oklahoma City |
| Second Team | ||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| Pitcher | Jennifer Elias | Houston Baptist (TX) |
| Pitcher | Diana Kendrick | Athens State (AL) |
| Pitcher |
Nikki Wilson | Mobile (AL) |
| Pitcher |
Saysha Sappenfield | William Woods (MO) |
| Catcher | Tammy Lucas | William Woods (MO) |
| Catcher | Kim Stanfill | Belmont (TN) |
| Infield | Robbin Beeler | William Woods (MO) |
| Infield |
Jennifer Carruth | Houston Baptist (TX) |
| Infield |
Jodi Foye | West Florida |
| Infield |
Li Luckmeier | Westminster (PA) |
| Infield |
Lisa Pauley | St. Francis (IL) |
| Infield |
Teresa Sheets | Mount Vernon Nazarene (OH) |
| Infield | Belinda Stein | Mobile (AL) |
| Infield | Bobbi Towers | Oklahoma City |
| Outfield | Shana Hilyard | Western Oregon |
| Outfield |
Kerry Keegan | St. Mary (NE) |
| Outfield |
Danetta Laguna | Pacific Lutheran (WA) |
| Designated Player |
Laura Rivers | Houston Baptist (TX) |
| Designated Player |
Jenny Kindle | Pacific Lutheran (WA) |
| Utility |
Kelly Kennedy | Indiana Wesleyan |
| Third Team | ||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| Pitcher | Miah Coe | Belmont (TN) |
| Pitcher | Megan Mertins | St. Mary (NE) |
| Infield |
Janice Alexander | Athens State (AL) |
| Outfield |
Lia Kahele | Hawaii Pacific |
| Designated Player | Kelly Johnson | Mobile (AL) |
| Designated Player | Carrie Mann | Westminster (PA) |
