Louisville Slugger/NFCA 1999 NAIA All-America Teams
| First Team |
||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| Pitcher | Kathy Iggulden | Simon Fraser (BC) |
| Pitcher | Dolly Johnson | Oklahoma City |
| Pitcher | Corrie Allen | Olivet Nazarene (IL) |
| Pitcher | Jennifer Cunningham | Spring Hill (AL) |
| Catcher | Megan Daly | Bethel (IN) |
| First Base | Kelly Austene | Lindenwood (MO) |
| Second Base | Cindy Yan | Oklahoma City |
| Third Base |
Sharon Marquardt | McKendree (IL) |
| Shortstop |
Tina Papatolis | Simon Fraser (BC) |
| Outfield |
April Allison | Bethel (IN) |
| Outfield |
Sasha Olson | Simon Fraser (BC) |
| Outfield | Kara Winkler | North Georgia College and State |
| Utility | Olivia Jarc | Southern Wesleyan (SC) |
| Second Team | ||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| Pitcher | Robin Lisak | Eastern Oregon |
| Pitcher | Sallie Henry | Lindenwood (MO) |
| Pitcher | Jennifer Ridenoure | Nova Southeastern (FL) |
| Catcher | Kathy Spies | Houston Baptist (TX) |
| First Base | Kim Pacer | Ohio Dominican |
| Second Base | Shannon Sawyer | Nova Southeastern (FL) |
| Third Base | Angela Lichty | Simon Fraser (BC) |
| Shortstop | Christie Liu | Oklahoma City |
| Outfield | Kim Mahoney | Caldwell (NJ) |
| Outfield |
Jana Sagara | Menlo (CA) |
| Outfield | Jamie Whiteman | Oklahoma City |
| Utility | Amy Lehmer | Walsh (OH) |
