2009 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NAIA All-America Teams
| First Team |
||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| P | Tory Ferreira |
California Baptist |
| P | Sharon Bell |
St. Gregory's |
| C | Erin Slettvet |
Oklahoma City |
| 1B | Nikki Lowe |
California Baptist |
| 2B | Ginalee Davis |
Lubbock |
| 3B | Jody Lantz |
Dickinson State |
| SS | Ashley Boyd |
California Baptist |
| DP | Kelly Griego |
Lubbock Christian |
| UT | Johana Gomez |
Lee |
| OF | Amanda Howard |
Oklahoma City |
| OF | Mallory Meadows |
Belhaven |
| OF | Kendra Corbin |
Evangel |
| OF |
Mandy Cripe |
Bethel |
| At-Large/SS | Raquel Hawkins |
Lubbock Christian |
| At-Large/UT | Melissa Gomez |
Point Loma Nazarene |
| At-Large/3B | Jineth Pimental |
Mobile |
| Second Team | ||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| P | Sara Jane Webster |
Dickinson State |
| P | Alyssa Gutierrez |
Lubbock Christian |
| C | Courtney Reynaga |
St. Gregory's |
| C | Judy Barber |
William Carey |
| 1B | Tyanna Helton |
William Penn |
| 2B | Jackie Plough |
Aquinas (MI) |
| 3B | Honda Rodriguez |
Lubbock Christian |
| SS |
Brittany Webb |
Belhaven |
| DP | Breanna Canclini |
Evangel |
| UT | Nicole Marcoux |
Dickinson State |
| OF | Jessie Harris |
Simon Fraser |
| OF | Ashley Aspinall |
Aquinas (MI) |
| OF | Tan Montgomery |
William Carey |
| At-Large/3B | Courtney Mienkina |
Savannah College of Art & Design |
| At-Large/3B | Bailey Dillender |
Campbelsville |
| At-Large/P | Tyler Lent |
Point Loma Nazarene |
