2010 Louisville Slugger/NFCA NAIA All-America Teams
| First Team |
||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| P | Emma Holden |
California Baptist |
| C | Brittney Fisher |
Bethel (Ind.) |
| 1B | Katie Hale |
Southern Nazarene |
| 2B | Britney Webb |
Belhaven |
| 3B | Judy Barber |
William Carey |
| SS | Ashley Boyd |
California Baptist |
| OF | Tiffany Adams |
Shorter |
| OF | Marissa Baker |
Olivet Nazarene |
| OF | Tina Galinato |
California Baptist |
| UT | Johana Gomez |
Lee |
| DP | Stafani Durrant |
Simon Fraser |
| At-Large/P | Sarah Burns |
Belhaven |
| At-Large/1B | Alyssa Dronenberg |
Cal State San Marcos |
| At-Large/2B | Brianna Corral |
California Baptist |
| At-Large/OF | Amanda Howard |
Oklahoma City |
| At-Large/UT | Kendall Gorham | California Baptist |
| Second Team | ||
| Pos. | Player | School |
| P | Tory Ferreira |
Califonia Baptist |
| P | Ashley Wilburn |
Oklahoma City |
| C | Nicole Shoemaker |
Califonia Baptist |
| 1B | Caitlin Gidcumb |
Olivet Nazarene |
| 2B | Rachel Comoglio | Olivet Nazarene |
| 3B | Allison Hinton | Houston-Victoria |
| 3B | Christina Jaques | Belhaven |
| SS | Jessie Harris | Simon Fraser |
| OF | Megan Paradzinskie |
St. Xavier |
| OF | Carleigh Shannon | Savannah Art & Design |
| OF | Lindsey Tuter | Ottawa |
| DP | Katie Boocher | Bethel (IN) |
| UT | Chelsea Brancheau | Spring Arbor |
| DP | Brianna Payne | Mid-America Nazarene |
| At-Large | Jordan Reynolds | Olivet Nazarene |
| At-Large | Valerie Teter | Columbia (MO) |
