NCAA DI | NCAA DII | NCAA DIII | NAIA | NJCAA DI | NJCAA DII | NJCAA DIII | Cal JC | NWAC | High School
NFCA Diamond Sports/Division II Catchers of the Year
| Year | Name | School |
| 2022 | Ashley Perez | University of Texas at Tyler |
| 2021 | Shanna McBroom | West Texas A&M University |
| 2020 | Award Not Presented | |
| 2019 | Julia Seader | Long Island University Post |
| 2018 | Mariah Jameyson | Texas A&M University-Commerce |
| 2017 | Marisa Monasseri | Caldwell University |
| 2016 | Haley Hodges | University of Southern Indiana |
| 2016 | Marla Reiter | Dixie State University |
| 2014 | Natalie Wideman | California University of Pennsylvania |
| 2013 | Kim Jerrick | Midwestern State University |
| 2012 | Nathalie Timmermans | University of Central Oklahoma |
| 2011 | Christine Roser | Rollins College |
| 2010 | Alyssa Shirey | Valdosta State University |
| 2009 | Christine Roser | Rollins College |
| 2008 | Jessica Shiery | Abilene Christian |
| 2007 | Amber Lanier | Columbus State University |
| 2006 | Jessica Padilla | Humboldt State University |
| 2005 | Liz Beyer | St. Mary’s University (Texas) |
| 2004 | Crystal Krebs | University of Colorado, Colorado Springs |
| 2003 | Jami Ingram | Texas Women's University |
| 2002 | Tracie Schioppi | Cal State University, San Bernardino |
| 2001 | Blake Baskin | Kennesaw State University |
| 2000 | Audra Thomas | Kennesaw State University |
| 2000 | Audra Thomas | Kennesaw State University |
| 1998 | Meghan Hunsinger | Bloomsburg University |
| 1997 | Meghan Hunsinger | Bloomsburg University |
